Notes From the Edge
Issue #306
August 6, 2008


Messages for Jon

Soul Traveler

Brother Of Mine

Iechyd Dda, Jon. (Good Health, Jon.)

Bless You

Get Well, Jon

Hope to See You Soon

Thank You

Keep on Keeping On!

I Make the Best Pizzas - Stop By

Get Well & Peace

Media

Rick Wakeman Video Vault Released at Last!

Interview with Tony Kaye and Billy Sherwood

DVD Review - A Yes By Any Other Name

HOF

Yes into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

Rock and Rock Hall of Fame

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame: Do We Really Care?

If Politics Were Left Out

Snub the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame

Tribute Bands

Comments regarding tribute bands

Standing Ovations

Yes tribute band in Nashville

Offered

Jon & Yes VHS for sale

Dialog

The Magic of Yes

Laserdisc

Yes at IMAX

Cover version of “Long Distance Runaround'

Jon Anderson & Glass Hammer visit the south Side of the Sky

Conspiracy

Yes Re-Formulating

Arriving UFO

Passing the Torch

If It Doesn't Have Jon...

Time Keeps Ticking

Yes Moving Forward

Remember the RELAYER tour?

All Things Must Pass

 


Messages for Jon

Soul Traveler

From:   Dave Braun   cosmic.rocker@hotmail.com
Location:  Ft. Wayne, IN  USA

Thank you for everything in my lifetime. You are my biggest inspiration. My prayers and hope are with you, get better soon!!

Brother Of Mine

From:   Ron Kerr   retrugger1@gmail.com
Location:  Edmond, OK  USA

Best wishes for your recovery. Hang in there, brother. When you're ready so are we!

Iechyd Dda, Jon. (Good Health, Jon.)

From:   Bryan Cokely   nesaf@aapt.net,au
Location:  Sydney, NSW  Australia

Dear Jon, thanks for the wonderful show in Sydney 2003. Great memories. Never mind us , the fans, just get better for your own sake. You deserve good health at this time for the benefit of you and your family.

Thinking of you. Bryan and Emily (aged 7).

Bless You

From:   Brian Lynch   brialynch@aol.com
Location:  Rochester, NY  USA

I wish God's blessing on you and your family that you return to good health. Thank you for all of your wonderful music with one of the greatest bands ever. Take care. God bless you.

Get Well, Jon

From:   Danny Amantea   yesfiend1204@aol.com
Location:  mohegan lake, ny  usa

Wishing you all my best for a speedy recovery, Jon. We all love and miss you. I have enjoyed over 150 live yes shows as well as over 15 of your solo projects as far back as 1975.

GET WELL SOON! YOU ARE IN MY PRAYERS.

Hope to See You Soon

From:   Brian O'Keefe   btokeefe@sbcglobal.net
Location:  St. Louis, Missouri  USA

Jon, sorry to hear about your recent illness. Take some time off and get better so that you can be back giving us many years of great music.

Thank You

From:   Christopher Winsor   tarheel93chris@hotmail.com
Location:  Boone, NC  United States

You are an amazing ray of light. Thank you for your wonderful music. I love you voice and lyrics. You are such and inspiration.

Keep on Keeping On!

From:   Grant Baynham   grant@jazzyb2.demon.co.uk
Location:  Hereford, UK  England

We are all getting older together. You have contributed so much to this world by your music, keep well, get strong, we need you!

I Make the Best Pizzas - Stop By

From:   John Randazzo   enigma757@verizon.net
Location:  Rockville Centre, NY  USA

Jon, no matter how many years pass, you and your music, both inside Yes and solo, are something I feel lucky to have. I cannot imagine the feelings from enjoying musical artistry, recording, touring, fame and the bonding with friends from youth who are clearly more than brothers.

You have been blessed - which I know you're aware.

Now in this time of healing, be kind to yourself. You've given so much to so many. And I would like to return some of the love, by offering to make you one of my special pizzas -

So, the next time you're in NY and on Long Island (not far from Jones Beach in fact), you, Jane and family too are welcome to stop over for some quality quiet time and perhaps a glass of wine. I'll make it with toppings of your choice (give me a hint in advance !)

Be well brother - speedy recovery, blessings and peace.

Get Well & Peace

From:   Joe Ward   josephw@joswardpaintingco.com
Location:  St. Louis, MO  USA

After reading of Jon's health issue I pray & send good vibes his way. He has been an inspiration for many years in my life. His music has brought peace to my soul and now, hopefully I can send some back to his. Peace on you Jon. Get well soon.



Media

Rick Wakeman Video Vault Released at Last!

From:   Rob Ayling   voiceprintpr@googlemail.com
Location:  Houghton-Le-Spring, Tyne&Wear  England

Rick Wakeman Video Vault Released at Last!!!

After many months of research and planning, not to mention restoration in certain cases, the Rick Wakeman Video Vault is ready to go. Fans of Rick Wakeman have long wanted a visual document from some of Rick's classic solo shows from the seventies and the eighties and the Wakeman Video Vault aims to provide just what the fans want. This beautifully packaged box set is limited to just 1,000 copies.

The boxed set includes some of his greatest performances including King Arthur on Ice, Live at Wembley Empire Pool 1975, and 1984 filmed at the Hammersmith Odeon in 1981.

For a short video preview, full details of the contents and ordering details of the box please go to:

http://www.wakemanvideovault.com 

You can see full details of each DVD by clicking on the button at the top of each spine.

Interview with Tony Kaye and Billy Sherwood

From:   Jon Dawson   jdawson@freedomenc.com
Location:  Kinston, NC  USA

I recently interviewed Tony Kaye and Billy Sherwood of Yes and CIRCA. The idea was to ask questions that hadn't been asked a thousand times already, and I think it turned out well.

The interview can be read here: http://jdawson.encblogs.com/?p=88

DVD Review - A Yes By Any Other Name

From:   Dale Nickey   maemaeman@aol.com
Location:  Thousand Oaks, CA   USA

“An Evening Of Yes Music Plus” performed by Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe.

Stunning ABWH release finally gives long suffering Yes fans a proper concert film.

I read all the horror stories on Amazon. Poor sound. Poor video quality. No Chris Squire. While this release is far from polished, the intermittent gaffes of sound or video editing should not taint your enjoyment of (what may well be) the groups finest concert on film. As for Chris Squire, well... Frankly, in this context, I don’t give a damn.

Long held Yes orthodoxy maintains that Chris Squire is the only Yes member to appear in every incarnation of the group. Ergo, any group without him is not Yes. Wrong. If we stipulate that Yes has carried on in various forms despite the absence of Jon Anderson, Steve Howe, Rick Wakeman and Bill Bruford; then a group comprising all of those musicians is Yes. Case closed.

“An Evening Of Yes Music Plus” was performed and recorded in concert at the Shoreline Amp theater; a cozy, atmospheric little venue in Northern California. The concert starts as Jon Anderson takes a sunset stroll through the assembled multitude shaking hands and making his way to the stage. All the while singing “Time And A Word”. He then performs a solo mini-set comprising “Word”, and “Owner Of A Lonely Heart”. He performs solo to the discrete accompaniment by a support guitarist. Jon is resplendent in a gold and white sequined military jacket and blond perm. A pint size Celtic Golden God. Indeed, this is the last era of Yes where the vestiges of youth still remained and they could gussy up and give an audience a boner. The spiteful indignities of their dotage were still a decade away.

After Jon’s charming appetizer, Steve Howe took the solo baton and performed “Clap” and “Mood For A Day”. Both pieces received resounding ovations from the appreciative audience. Howe was animated, and engaging. Each piece boasted nice new musical intros and were played with command, confidence and invention.

Rick Wakeman was next up and played an energetic medley of his fastest and prettiest right hand exercises. He is Rick Wakeman after all. The Liberace” of our time... not a bad thing.

Bill Bruford enters into the proceedings by dancing and playing tambourine to “Long Distance Runaround”. He looks youngish and fit. When he sits behind the kit kicks in on the second verse, the (true) classic Yes incarnation announces its arrival into the building.

Bruford helmed the drum chair in Yes from it’s inception in 1969 thru “Close To The Edge” and part of YESSONGS. He then quit Yes very much on his own terms at their peak of critical popularity and moved on to progressive rock legend with King Crimson during their most challenging and popular period. During his absence, Yes experienced a long, graceful and imperial decline in record sales halted only by the rising phoenix that was 90125.

So far as ABWH is concerned, Bruford mystique” and pedigree is rewarded with ownership of the “New Yes” backline rhythm section. Bruford’s first call bassist Tony Levin was ill and unavailable for the tour (damn). Jeff Berlin former “Bruford Band” member deputized in the roll of “Chris Squire” and acquits himself well. Bruford’s electronic/acoustic kit gives a clean large drum presence to the band. The majority of the bass frequencies in the mix are coming courtesy of Bruford’s left foot. Jeff Berlin played all Yes and ABWH bass parts cleanly and expertly. His place in the mix would seem to reflect Mr. Bruford’s tastes.

ABWH itself was a stern and bold counter punch to the “West Coast” Yes that revived the Yes franchise with the #1 hit, “Owner Of A Lonely Heart”. The one link common to both bands being double agent Jon Anderson. The new Yes music is bright, sparkly positive and full of portentous new wave cheerleading. The new music is also where one most notices the absence of Chris Squire. This group certainly earned another kick at the can. However, their chance to record a proper follow-up morphed into the Frankenstein monster UNION and one might argue, squandered.

The “concert film” is a fickle medium. Some bands get lucky and capture lightning in a bottle, and secure their moment in time. In so doing, create a mystical plain where music, audience, drugs and cameras harmonically converge to define an era, time and place. The Band are forever blessed with “The Last Waltz”, George Harrison legacy is secured with “Bangladesh”, For better or worse The Rolling Stones will always burn our memories with “Gimme Shelter” and the Beatles burnished their mythology with “The Rooftop Concert” in Let It Be.

Yes has never had their “moment”. Yes has given their fan base tantalizing morsels in DVD release. YESSONGS and “Live At The House Of Blues”. However, too many offerings are simply stocking stuffers. “Live At Philadelphia” and KEYS TO ASCENSION being the most irritating examples.

For the Yes fan, this may well be The One. Money and technology could even improve this release further. “An Evening Of Yes Music Plus” captures a magic moment in Yes history even if nobody was listening outside the confines of the Shoreline Amp theater. This DVD film has good sound, nice camera angles and an attractive and magnetic band burning brightly in a stylish setting. The icing on the cake is a large, likable and adoring audience feeding the band Grade A cosmic energy.

I don’t mind remembering Yes this way.



HOF

Yes into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

From:   Michael Smerconish   kmedia09@aol.com
Location:  Philadelphia, PA  USA

Please come visit my "office." Check out my new website at
http://www.mastalk.com. In honor of Jon Anderson's visit to my studio, click on the Yes CD - Close to the Edge - and sign my petition to get Yes into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

Rock and Rock Hall of Fame

From:   Mark Egerton   magma_magma4@hotmail.com
Location:  London, UK 

IMHO the whole idea of a rock and roll hall of fame is so cabaret and camp that we really shouldn't want Yes to be in it - please can anyone tell me why they think the so-called Hall of Fame is a good idea? Would love to get my head around it, rather than just thinking that the whole concept is sooooooo silly.

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame: Do We Really Care?

From:   Barry Garner   barry.garner@yahoo.com
Location:  New York, NY  USA

Music like art in general is highly subjective and the debate raging for centuries has been the evaluation of art which has become especially problematic since the 20th century. At a minimum there are three approaches: the Realist, whereby aesthetic quality is an absolute value independent of any human view; the Objectivist, whereby it is also an absolute value, but is dependent on general human experience; and the Relativist position, whereby it is not an absolute value, but depends on, and varies with, the human experience of different humans. I'd like to think we are mostly Relativists or at the least Objectivists. Caring about the RRHOF makes us Realists and legitimizes the RRHOF as the absolute arbiter of musical taste. Year in and out there is an outcry by Yes fans expressing the gamut of emotions from dismay to anger at Yes” continued omission on the yearly inductee list. Folks, come on! do we really care? Do we need someone else's confirmation of our beliefs to legitimize how we feel about Yes and Yes music?

At this point, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has been so thoroughly diluted that, it would be embarrassing to have Yes inducted to stand along side the throngs of mediocrity and drivel that has been inducted over the years. (Yes, that is my subjective opinion too). I can honestly say that it never once has crossed my mind while laying on my floor with head phones, or listening in my car to Gates of Delirium, why yes hasn't been inducted. Yes music is precious to me it has been from day one when I was 12 and is to this day at 43. Like most organized institutions, the RRHOF is about politics not music. Need I say more?

If Politics Were Left Out

From:   William E. Surdi   wsurdi@msn.com
Location:  Phoenix, Arizona  USA

Thank You Mike for your humble thoughts of the Rock in Roll Hall of Fame. Yes does belong there without a doubt. The band members have given so much to humanity that the lawyers in the industry do not care.

Snub the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame

From:   Joe Delia   jldelia@hotmail.com
Location:  Norwalk, CT  USA

The time will come in the not too distant future when the folks at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame come knocking on Yes's door. I can only hope they reply with an emphatic "Thanks, but no thanks!” Yes is obviously a band that should have been enshrined long before several of the more recent inductees, and I would love to see the look on the faces of those in Cleveland with egg on their face.



Tribute Bands

Comments regarding tribute bands

From:   Brad DeWitt   bdewitt@insightbb.com
Location:  Indianapolis, IN  USA

Just wanted to send you a note regarding the subject of tribute bands.

I feel much the same as the comments submitted by Lee Gately (the "YesMan") that when I attend a tribute band performance, it is a great way to meet up this other fans who typically want to experience the same music that the tribute band is able to reproduce. Often, the tracks performed by these bands are more desirable from a fans perspective, as they usually attempt to tackle songs that they themselves would like to actual band to perform live, but may no longer play for whatever reason.

I bumped into Lee one time a Paladino's while living in LA and I really miss that club. They would have 3 tribute bands perform almost every Saturday night and I got to experience music from Pink Floyd, RUSH, Yes, Genesis, ELP, Led Zeppelin, The Who, Steely Dan and so on.

While some tribute bands are better than others at reproducing the songs of the original artist, the really good ones are worth seeing every time (Which One's Pink and Led Zeppagain are prime examples). The only Yes tribute I have see is called "Roundabout" and I believe they are based in San Diego. While they may not reproduce an entirely faithful copy of the original, they are quite good and provide a valuable alternative to the real thing.

One particular tribute band worth mentioning is the now disbanded Genesis tribute "Cinema Show". These guys were exceptional and were never shy when it came to performing the challenging material. In fact, their former (now deceased) lead singer, Shaun Guerin, had multiple solo recordings released and was featured on a Genesis tribute album ("Various artists - A Tribute to Genesis"). Shaun was terrific as the lead singer for Cinema Show and also played drums and flute. Cinema Show once performed an almost 3-hour show at the Scherr Forum Theatre within the Thousand Oaks Civic Arts Plaza. That performance is still one of the finest shows I have ever seen by any artist.

So my position is that tribute bands are definitely a good thing. So long as there are talented musicians out there who share a passion for the music we love and are willing to perform it live for us fans, how can that be a bad thing?

Also, I loved your editorial about Yes and their inability to be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Shame. Personally, I hope Yes is never recognized by such a suspect organization and perhaps someday the general public will see what a joke the RRHoF really is.

Standing Ovations

From:   Jean-François PENICHOUX   jean.penichoux@wanadoo.fr
Location:  CUSSANGY, FRANCE

To add a few words to the cover band topic, I don’t think this is worthwhile. A band without at least Howe, Anderson or Squire would not be Yes. Whatever the skills of the musicians. If, in the sixties, very few musicians were able to play these complex parts, it is not the case today. Players have improved so much. Listening to these kids just out of the music schools is amazing. They can play anything. But what do they do with this technique? Yes has never been only a question of technique, but to be good enough on your stool to be totally free and able to play whatever you feel at the very moment.

I don’t know how it is in America, but I can tell you that in France, people are very calm and listening very carefully during the tracks and burst only after the last note expire. I saw Yes every time they went to Europe since 1992 that means 6 times in Paris and one time in London. In Paris, it was standing ovations after each song. I am 52 and I have attended hundreds of shows, I have never seen a thing like this. Very moving. I can assure you these ovations were not intended to a band named Yes but to Jon, Steve, Chris, Rick and Alan. This is a so special blend, another combination with other musicians couldn’t give me the emotion I feel when I listen to these guys I am so grateful to.

So on a personal statement: I would not be interested in a band covering Yes stuff.

Yes tribute band in Nashville

From:   Frank List   franzstuka@yahoo.com
Location:  Nashville, TN  USA

I dunno if this is the proper venue for such a proposal, but I would dearly LOVE to help create a yes-trib band for Nashville.

there's a LOT of musicians in this little berg, and all who are even marginally aware understand that Yes changed the landscape of music forever...practically every picker in town tries to play a bit of “Clap”, and “Mood for a Day” (I work “Mood” and “Leaves of Green” into every wedding I play--and I play a BUNCH!!)

that being said, dear readers, consider this an invitation to respond and research to release, release your inner Yes thang, and let's get busy.



Offered

Jon & Yes VHS for sale

From:   Chris Ravndal   cravndal@comcast.net
Location:  Minneapolis, MN  USA

At the time it first became available, I bought a copy of Jon's "Indigenous Journey" VHS. I've watched it about 2-3x max. I just don't need to hang onto it. I also have "9012Live" and "Yes” Greatest Video Hits" on VHS. The 90121Live box is closed on all sides and I'm pretty sure I've never watched that since I bought it.

Make me an offer for one, two, or all three and add $4(US) for shipping.



Dialog

The Magic of Yes

From:   Newton Suwe   njsuwe@sbcglobal.net
Location:  Oak Park, IL  The Big One

In these bleak days of the Dark Ages we live in, where...

Truth is mocked
Integrity is held in contempt
Compassion is disdained
Justice belongs to those who could afford it
Ignorance is a virtue

...there is a magic formula to brighten your own vision of the world. At least temporarily.

THE LADDER (circa 1999). Listen to it - again. Loud. Air guitar it. Sing along with it. Forget about your neighbors who may well wonder who's torturing a cat over there. Just sing it.

And as you wind through the entire album and get to the last song, "Nine Voices" (no fair jumping ahead), don't just sing along - belt it out.

And when the album is over - you'll find that the world is somehow a better place than it was an hour earlier. Try it.

Laserdisc

From:   Gary Kowalchuk   TServo137@msn.com
Location:  Sparta , TN  USA

Does anyone know if "The UNION Tour" is still available on Laserdisc. Mine got ruined before I had a chance to play it. I won an eBay auction for the DVD but when it arrived it was a bootleg. I know Laserdisc aren't even manufactured any longer but if there is a Yesfan with a "connection" please email me.

Yes at IMAX

From:   Danny McCabe   danthemangcc@hotmail.com
Location:  Glasgow, Lanarkshir  Scotland

It occurs to me, now that Yes have released Live at Montreaux as an HD-DVD, how about getting the film onto IMAX screens across the country? It could even be done in a similar way to the Yes Acoustic/Yesspeak event of a few years ago.

Members of the band have intimated in interviews that the 40th anniversary is coming up and that they would like to organise some kind of musical event. If the band recorded some new material and did some kind of live performance, supplemented by some classic material, they could have, say, a screening of the Montreaux gig, followed by the live performance, broadcast using hi-def cameras.

Obviously, there aren't that many IMAX theatres around, so it could be supplemented by screenings in other cinemas.

This could, then be followed by a slightly shorter than usual tour to keep the band from getting too knackered!

It's a possibility, and one they could maybe find ways to elaborate upon for even greater impact - 3-D Montreaux, anyone?!?

I really think this idea warrants some merit and I'd like to think the band would consider it a possibility.

Cover version of “Long Distance Runaround'

From:   Bjørn Clasen   misiumail@gmail.com
Location:  Rollengergronn, n/a  Grand Duchy of Luxembourg

Crazy but wide-spanning Danish rock band A Kid Hereafter have released a cover version of “Long Distance Runaround”. You can listen to it on the band's MySpace: http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=57510878 

Jon Anderson & Glass Hammer visit the south Side of the Sky

From:   Rick Kadello   rick@kadellolarsen.com
Location:  Windsor, Ca  U.S.

I’ve been to the other side and back and I’m here to say progressive music is live and well! I’m not sure if most Yes fans are aware of the collaboration of Jon Anderson with GLASS HAMMER. Their new album “Culture of Ascent” is a fine effort from start to finish. Having Jon’s input on a couple of the tracks surely didn’t hurt either. It is obvious why Jon would choose to work with this band as they exemplify all of what has made Yes great and little, if any, of what has had Yes fans bemoaning the past few years.

Jon’s efforts are on tracks one and three. The first just happens to be a cover of “South Side of the Sky”. The beginning of the song is nicely reworked with Jon providing vocalizations at the intro and periodically throughout. Curiously he doesn’t do the lead vocal but fades in and out - a nice reminder of whose song this really is - and yet GH makes it their own. Nicely done as it is a fresh spin, but respectfully keeps the integrity of the original version. Amusingly, the track ends with the “walking footsteps” effect - an obvious tip of the hat to Yes” early works. I realize any cover of a Yes song by another band may take time to digest and appreciate, but IMHO it works.

Track three, “Life by Light”, Jon’s second work on the album also only uses vocalizations but to great effect. Again, he fades in and out of the piece. The opening sequence of the song is absolutely hypnotic. You can almost close your eyes and see Yes playing this song. One might envision this being a work that would have fallen somewhere between TFTO and GFTO in the Yes catalogue.

From this point the rest of the album is all GH, but the Yes influence is still quite noticeable. However, it should be noted they are not a Yes cover band (as so heatedly discussed in recent issues) nor are they a knock-off band either. They are definitely bringing something fresh and lively to the progressive music world. Momentarily I will share how I think the bands are similar and how they differ, but first I think it is worth spending a moment or two on the other songs on the album.
The second track, “Sun Song”, is simply (again IMHO) one of the best progressive music pieces made in the last ten years, maybe the last twenty. It’s that good, nearly perfect. The lyrics are entertaining (albeit not “deep’) and the musical interlude for about half of the song is just wonderfully creative and energetic. This one track is well worth the price of admission! Tracks four and five, “Ember with out Light” and “Into Thin Air” respectively, are monsters clocking in at 16:38 and 19:19. Both pieces are somewhat complicated epics with interwoven lyrical and musical themes coming to the fore and fading away making room for exploration of separate musical ideas but never forgetting they’re part of a whole work. The styles, pace, and moods vary throughout leaving one with the impression that you’ll hear a little something new each time you listen. The final track, “rest” is aptly named as it gears the album down to close it out.

So, all that being said, wherein do the similarities of the bands lie? Clearly GH has been influenced by Yes - working with Jon being an obvious indicator of that. Lyrically they are interesting, somewhat enigmatic as the best of Jon’s lyrics have been. Yet they are not so out there as to be nonsensical. Like Yes, I think the lyrics come off generally uplifting, subject to interpretation, and are not adolescent - this final aspect being something I can’t take at my age. (Yes fan for over 30 years - you figure it out! Hint - I still use the word “album‘)
Musically they capture all the best of the range of Yes music. The keys run from stripped down piano solos to soaring synths of Rick’s heyday. The lead guitar like Steve’s work at times is very “tonal and spatial” and at other times races off with great energy. The base guitar work pops out in many of the tracks having the flavor of Chris” best work. The drumming and percussion has it’s moments in the sun too. Stylistically, the music ranges from discordant and edgy to ethereal and beautiful.

Additionally, the album is a concept work based loosely on mountain climbing. The pieces don’t directly interrelate, but the general theme comes up directly or indirectly in all of the songs. No doubt this made “South Side of the Sky” the appropriate song for them to cover. The shortest song on the album clocks in at 6:36. That has to remind us of when no yes song seemed to be under nine minutes or so, and yet we were always left wanting the songs to go on a little longer. Same general feeling with these songs.

So how are they different, and is it good or bad? One particular way is the use of violin in this album. As a Yes fan our first reaction might be MAGNIFICATION. The use of orchestra by Yes was a logical outgrowth of their progression and yet many of us were left wondering if it really worked or not. However, this is not the case here, but the primary reason is that the violins do not come off classical but much more as progressive jazz. Rather then, we should think “RELAYER” in this respect. In short, an interesting blend of ideas well integrated together.

At this point in the area of differences, I am inclined to digress some and comment on what seemed an interesting contradiction involving Jon’s work on this album. IMHO his vocalizations have the “world music” feel that he has brought to a number of the more recent Yes albums. The contradiction is that it works marvelously on this album and blends in seamlessly, a real compliment to the progressive nature of the album. However, I feel this very same element in Yes music has become too prominent and has overshadowed the progressive aspect of the band. As such I can’t help feel this is a big part of why Yes has stalled, and seemingly doesn’t know where to go, and maybe doesn‘t even want to try. They have lost their identity. And yet I, like so many others, think that if the balance between the music and the lyrical style can be re-balanced there may be another classic Yes album or two left to be made. It’s high time to go back to the essence of their roots but not forget we‘re in a new century.

In conclusion (I certainly have rambled on long enough now) I do recommend that Yes fans check GH out if you’ve not heard any of their music. I have only heard this one album - one of those “if Jon’s contributing to it, it must be good” purchases. In looking at various progressive music sites they are not a new band and they have several critically acclaimed albums.

The ultimate praise to any band is the influence they leave on the bands that follow them in their genre. Yes has certainly had that effect here on GH and yet it’s important to emphasize that GH is not a mere copy cat cover act but is truly building on what Yes (and other prog. Bands) have established to make fresh and creative new progressive music. Give it a listen - you won’t be disappointed. Progressive music is live and well...

Conspiracy

From:   Jason Engstrom   inturmoil@msn.com
Location:  Seabeck, WA  USA

The future of Yes should be more music from Conspiracy. We don't need any more "greatest hits" tours. Just my opinion.

If yes is going to tour, it should be to support a new album and Billy Sherwood should be part of the band. Once again, just my opinion.
I have a feeling I'm going to be in trouble for this one.

Yes Re-Formulating

From:   David Carlin   david.j.carlin@verizon.net
Location:  Philadelphia, PA  USA

I want to wish Jon the best of health. I appreciate the chance of having my voice heard. What I am about to say may be blunt, but I feel it is needed for the future of my favorite band and I have followed Yes for over 28 years.

First let me say this: There is a nucleus to this band that must stay the same. Anderson, Squire, Howe are the Key center as I see it. If a lineup changes these individuals, the band will clearly suffer on any new music composed. Changing Anderson with another singer will only lead to problems of comparison with Jon. Although in the past, Drama was recorded and was actually an excellent album, the performance factor of the older material will always render this a problem. White or Bruford could easily fill the drum area. Bruford or White on Drums would be fine. The Fans would admire either of the two. On the subject of Keyboards is actually the area where this gives Yes it's most flexibility. Although Wakeman is considered by many including myself as the classic lineup keyboardist, there still were very successful other players such as Moraz, Downes and Koroshev. All of these players contributed to new music. If Yes wishes to replace a Keyboardist, I suggest bringing in someone new who can contribute to the writing of new material.

Secondly: There have been indication or rumours that Jon may not want to pursue another tour with Yes. If this is the case, Yes should not tour without him. If the band must retire for good, I suggest each member write an autobiographical account of recording and being in Yes over the years. I myself along with multitudes of other fans would love to read about this. Chris Welch's book was ok, but a bandmember account would be far superior.

Thirdly: If Yes does re-group with the nucleus of the key members noted above, they should all write new music. This was clearly an issue with Wakeman. I believe he would be far more interested in supporting new music than going out for Anniversary tours for example. There are only so many times we can hear Roundabout and Starship Trooper. ( I love them both, just an example). I don't believe everyone's musical standards can live to be a copy of what they were without going into any new bold areas for which Yes is known for. Strong Melodies, Thought out structure, leads, and vocals / harmonies. They need to hunger for this again. I want to believe that they are not too old to do this. I still believe in this band and the potential. If any of the key members are not well, perhaps this should be taken into account as well and if this is the end or near the end, maybe they can drum up the strength to try and do one more great album and seal this off correctly.

Arriving UFO

From:   Pete Roche   pmroche@roadrunner.com
Location:  Cleveland, OH  USA

Future times will stand and clearly smile!

Perhaps the "UFO experience" will transpire, and a crystal-powered celestial transport shall indeed arrive and shuttle Maestro Anderson and company off-world, voyaging ever outward through infinite space, on a journey that physically manifests the sounds of "Awaken" as the crescendo / denouement rotates perpetually through the circle of fifths.

Either that, or a new album on earth. Naysayers who insist that age and health will prevent such a thing, check out what Mr. Howe did on the latest Asia album. I LOVE the guy, but frankly I didn't think he still had it in him. He proved me wrong, and the astral travelers will shuttle him away.

Passing the Torch

From:   Alan Kelly   akelly_98446@yahoo.com
Location:  Tacoma, WA  USA

More of a suggestion here than a prediction: Each member of Yes should interview/audition a musician to take his place. If each member found a suitable musician to replace him, the incoming Yes member could be coached and trained personally by the exiting Yes member.

I’m not talking about a cover band here. I’m talking about passing the torch to new band members. Jon Anderson is already doing this in part with the Rock School musicians. Perhaps Oliver Wakeman may already be a candidate for the keyboard.

After all, Rick Wakeman did say to the effect that there will always be a Yes much like an orchestra with different members. Does the Philharmonic Orchestra cease from being what they are because of personnel turn-over?

Yes members may fade away but the music must not. New Yes music must come to pass.

The name of the band: Yes Again? Yes Squared? Yes Volume II? Yes, it can happen.

If It Doesn't Have Jon...

From:   Doug Roogler   undercraigs@talktalk.net
Location:  Glasgow, Scotland  UK

It simply isn't Yes. If there is a new singer being brought in then call it something else. We can then all judge what we think and let it stand on its own merits, not claim it is something it isn't.

Time Keeps Ticking

From:   Mark Weber   mweber@vlcpa.com
Location:  Cincinnati, Ohio  USA

Unfortunately father time is marching on. I fear we may have seen the boys in their glory for the last time. with the advancing ages and related health issues that have bit the band I can't see them coming back with the energy we are all use to. I hope I'm wrong.
Yes forever!

Yes Moving Forward

From:   Andy Wells   Andywells2008@comcast.net
Location:  Huntsville, AL  USA

It's time for Yes to starting training the next generation to take over the farm... Seeing as they have given up on creating new music... And have decided to become a ghost of themselves... I suppose the reason these old guys have been burning themselves out on greatest hits tours for the last 7 years is for the money... Thanks, Yes, for killing my interest in you...

Remember the RELAYER tour?

From:   Frank List   franzstuka@yahoo.com
Location:  Nashville, TN  USA

There was a lengthy entry in the Tour Program from the RELAYER tour, that was penned either by Jon or Don Lehmkuhl.

Does anyone have that program, and would be willing to share that entry? I remember that it was typically profound, and it occurs that what was written there may still have something to teach me.

All Things Must Pass

From:   Bill Wynne   wjwynne@hotmail.com
Location:  Manchester, NH  USA

With 42 shows since 1972 from Europe and all over the USA and Canada, Yes has been a part of my life and has allowed me to meet and mingle with some of the best people on this planet. The news of Jon's illness saddened many. With tickets to the Tampa, Orlando and Boston shows, many of us Yes Fans were meeting in Tampa as we do someplace on the tour. Also, a decision to cancel was not taken lightly by Jon, the band and management and likely costly as well.

As I grow older I personally realize that not only my time will come to a close but we all know that the time for Yes live performances will come to a close as well. For me there will be memories for family, and for Yes Fans there will always be music of Yes in our minds and available to play and enjoy as well. I have my plans, a Yes sticker affixed from the show in Belgium and three Yes tunes that will be played when I leave this world. Hopefully the band will return and in good health and hopefully I will be here to enjoy some travel and see some shows and great people. 


© 2008 Notes from the Edge
    webmaster@nfte.org